Carve the Mark

So I have read this book in its entirety. I held off on reading this when it first came out due to all the controversy surrounding it and just a general lack of interest as a result. I then decided it was best to listen to the audiobook rather than read it. That being said to me this book was a prequel. It was a lot of information dumping and attempted world building. We basically gained nothing in this book other than figuring out who the true enemy is.

This book heavily focuses on the two societies on the same planet. Especially considering Cyra comes from the powerful society whereas Akos is the peaceful side. The clear delineation between the two societies did bother me because no society is that black and white and while Roth attempted to show the diversity within each society, I think it was possible to do a better job. Looking back at the Divergent Series she did the same thing, each faction was very black and white in terms of their characterization, the only people who truly differed were Divergents in disguise which just adds to the almost cookie-cutter aspect of the societies.

I honestly do not think I would have been able to get through this book if not for the audiobook, the plot, if you can even call it that, drags in many places. The final few chapters are a rush of events that set up so many questions about what is truly going on and how the characters all fit together. I'll probably read the sequel eventually but it'll have to be the audiobook again I think. Hopefully the sequel has a better plot where I can see the purpose of characters actions and see how everything connects.