Aviv Snowberry
I really enjoyed the other two books in the series, and loved this one even more. It's really the culmination of the previous two books' plot threads, twists, and character development particularly between Laurent and Damen. It's a satisfying conclusion to their story and to their journey all the way from book 1. Sometimes I find that series ends will be unsatisfying, that the author will try too hard to make the last book stand out even as they've run out of steam, the entire Captive Prince Trilogy feels like one continuous story split into three parts. Of course each has its own distinct narrative arc for our deutrotagonists, but it's satisfying seeing everything you've read and learned reach the end you'd hope it would. In the last 1/4 of the book I was nearly jumping out of my seat at the events transpiring, and the end definitely made me tear up at the poetic book-ending that Pacat gave the story.
I really enjoyed the other two books in the series, and loved this one even more. It's really the culmination of the previous two books' plot threads, twists, and character development particularly between Laurent and Damen. It's a satisfying conclusion to their story and to their journey all the way from book 1. Sometimes I find that series ends will be unsatisfying, that the author will try too hard to make the last book stand out even as they've run out of steam, the entire Captive Prince Trilogy feels like one continuous story split into three parts. Of course each has its own distinct narrative arc for our deutrotagonists, but it's satisfying seeing everything you've read and learned reach the end you'd hope it would. In the last 1/4 of the book I was nearly jumping out of my seat at the events transpiring, and the end definitely made me tear up at the poetic book-ending that Pacat gave the story.
If I could leave no stars I likely would. I read the first book in the series on a whim (I wanted to read a Christian romance and was interested in the historical fiction element of it. This was far from my typical wheelhouse) And I understand that these books were written in the 1980s, and that our standards have changed. Yet at the same time I really did not like Elizabeth in this book.
In the first book it was comical when she would struggle with life on the Canadian frontier, maybe a little much, but throwing mouse traps into the boy's outhouse because she couldn't handle the thought of it being in the girl's made me roll my eyes but also chuckle. In this book I found her to be more on the insufferable side. Shout out to her husband, because he sure did pick a real one. That man has more patience than I would have in similar situations.
I also understand that this book is written from a Christian perspective, and I have no innate issues with that, but the book is also predicated on the spreading of the Gospel in the community Elizabeth moves into, which while accurate to those who moved into the north country and all, was still a little preachy and eyerolly (for me personally).
The reason I gave the book as low a star rating as I did was due to how obnoxious Elizabeth is in this book and also how racist parts of it are. Elizabeth becomes obsessed with wanting another white woman to be living in the town she moves to and it's really off putting when reading it. I understand what the author was trying to achieve with that, but I don't know that she did successfully. This was a book I read on a whim after reading the first one, and I don't think I will be continuing this series at all.
If I could leave no stars I likely would. I read the first book in the series on a whim (I wanted to read a Christian romance and was interested in the historical fiction element of it. This was far from my typical wheelhouse) And I understand that these books were written in the 1980s, and that our standards have changed. Yet at the same time I really did not like Elizabeth in this book.
In the first book it was comical when she would struggle with life on the Canadian frontier, maybe a little much, but throwing mouse traps into the boy's outhouse because she couldn't handle the thought of it being in the girl's made me roll my eyes but also chuckle. In this book I found her to be more on the insufferable side. Shout out to her husband, because he sure did pick a real one. That man has more patience than I would have in similar situations.
I also understand that this book is written from a Christian perspective, and I have no innate issues with that, but the book is also predicated on the spreading of the Gospel in the community Elizabeth moves into, which while accurate to those who moved into the north country and all, was still a little preachy and eyerolly (for me personally).
The reason I gave the book as low a star rating as I did was due to how obnoxious Elizabeth is in this book and also how racist parts of it are. Elizabeth becomes obsessed with wanting another white woman to be living in the town she moves to and it's really off putting when reading it. I understand what the author was trying to achieve with that, but I don't know that she did successfully. This was a book I read on a whim after reading the first one, and I don't think I will be continuing this series at all.
This is a romance novel that I would say is best summed up as doing perfectly what it says on the tin. Personally for me, neither the characters nor their trials and tribulations were particularly compelling to me. That being said I recognize that is my personal preferences and expectations of romance. I am no stranger to the average genre romance story, and this one with plenty of sex and a competitive sports college setting, is definitely in the realm of a rather traditional romance story arc. Which made it overall predictable and not in a way I found terribly compelling.
I think the messages of the story are good ones, the relationship is sweet and built up in a way that I think reflects a good and healthy relationship even with smatterings of enemies to lovers. But about a third of the way in I had to force myself into finishing the work, not because it was awful or anything but because I was just not invested. The work was a little over hyped online in my opinion, and I think that led to warped expectations. By the end of the story I was compelled by the developing plot beats but I wish it hadn't taken so long for me to feel that way.
Overall Icebreaker is a cute frenemies to lovers story doing exactly what it set out to do perfectly, it simply wasn't for me. I won't, however, be surprised to see this made into a film in about 5 years.
This is a romance novel that I would say is best summed up as doing perfectly what it says on the tin. Personally for me, neither the characters nor their trials and tribulations were particularly compelling to me. That being said I recognize that is my personal preferences and expectations of romance. I am no stranger to the average genre romance story, and this one with plenty of sex and a competitive sports college setting, is definitely in the realm of a rather traditional romance story arc. Which made it overall predictable and not in a way I found terribly compelling.
I think the messages of the story are good ones, the relationship is sweet and built up in a way that I think reflects a good and healthy relationship even with smatterings of enemies to lovers. But about a third of the way in I had to force myself into finishing the work, not because it was awful or anything but because I was just not invested. The work was a little over hyped online in my opinion, and I think that led to warped expectations. By the end of the story I was compelled by the developing plot beats but I wish it hadn't taken so long for me to feel that way.
Overall Icebreaker is a cute frenemies to lovers story doing exactly what it set out to do perfectly, it simply wasn't for me. I won't, however, be surprised to see this made into a film in about 5 years.
