| #2 |  The Chestnut Man
| 4.26 | 70 reads | |
| #3 |  Into the Water
| 3.37 | 160 reads | |
| #4 |  The Woman in Cabin 10
| 3.46 | 194 reads | |
| #5 |  The Shining Girls
| 3.52 | 131 reads | |
| #6 |  The Girl on the Train
| 3.51 | 874 reads | |
| #7 |  Broken Monsters
| 3.63 | 49 reads | |
| #8 |  In a Dark, Dark Wood
| 3.35 | 150 reads | |
| #9 |  Cult X
| 3 | 3 reads | |
| #10 |  Ninth House
| 4.02 | 600 reads | |
| #11 |  Lock Every Door
| 3.72 | 251 reads | |
| #12 |  The Sun Down Motel
| 3.85 | 156 reads | |
| #13 |  The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
| 3.79 | 334 reads | |
| #14 |  Home Before Dark
| 3.88 | 262 reads | |
| #15 |  Later
| 3.76 | 191 reads | |
| #16 |  All Her Little Secrets
| 3.81 | 19 reads |