Ship It

Ship It

2018 • 384 pages

Ratings7

Average rating1.9

15

Claire's an obsessed jerk. Let me just get that out ahead of everything else. Claire is one of two viewpoints in this book, and I won't even call her a protagonist, because Forest, the male viewpoint character, is FAR more sympathetic. Yeah, he's a touch homophobic at the beginning of the book, but he learns. Claire, on the other hand, has one goal that she's obsessed with and Will. Not. Let. It. Go. Single-minded determination can be a great thing, but Claire doesn't see or understand the harm she's doing in pursuing her goal. The few times she does see, she doesn't seem to care. Sure, she's sixteen, but holy crap, girl. Maybe, when people tell you a thing can't happen, you should stop and ask them why instead of stubbornly insisting it CAN happen if only they'll let it.

Let me back up slightly. Claire is a superfan of a show called Demon Heart. In the show, a demon hunter and a demon-with-a-heart play off each other in what the fans see as a romantic manner. This comes as a huge surprise to at least one of the stars of the show, Forest Reed, who plays the demon hunter. Forest has a rather disastrous interaction with Claire at a Q&A (he's an asshole about her question, which is about the two characters being gay) and the show decides, in order to salvage things, to have Claire travel with them to the next few public appearances, since she's a big name in the fandom. Forest sees this as a job he has to put up with for a paycheck. Claire sees this as a chance to make her ship real, and goes to - well - ridiculous lengths to convince the showrunners and stars.

Ultimately, Claire is right that representation is incredibly important. And she's probably even right that showrunners and stars should take risks with their careers to bring that representation to screen. But she's such an asshole about it that I can't even cheer her on. She's even kind of a jerk to Tess, the cute fanartist she meets at the first convention (and keeps running into at the ensuing cons).

Claire aside, I actually enjoyed the book. There were a couple of twists at the end that I very much enjoyed.

One bit I did NOT enjoy was Tess identifying as pan “because bi means two.” That definition of bisexual - that it's binary, only attracted to men and women - is biphobic and has NEVER been true. Bisexual means attracted to your own gender and others. That first definition tries to make bisexuals seem transphobic, and I'm frustrated that it persists. So it's disappointing to see the statement made in the book go unchallenged.

There's also an anxiety-inducing scene late in the book that I can't say much about because it's a major plot twist, but if you have issues with intimidating men, maayyyybe skip this one.

There is quite a bit of representation in the book, between Tess, the pansexual black girl, Claire, a questioning/queer white girl, and Forest, who is definitely questioning his sexuality, and learning about gender and sexuality representation issues from Claire. Oh, also Caty, a studio assistant, who is bisexual. (But who clarifies, unnecessarily, that she's attracted to boys and girls.)

So I'm quite torn on this book. I liked it, but it has issues.

You can find all my reviews and more at Goddess in the Stacks.

June 4, 2018Report this review