The Giant Rat of Sumatra

5/5 Stars!

“The Cursed Writer” by Holly Hepburn is a British historical mystery with a hint of cosiness that will surely appeal to fans of Sherlock Holmes and anyone who loves a thoughtfully crafted whodunit. Set in the 1930s in England, the second novel in the series follows Harriet White, a clever young woman relegated to working in the basement of a Baker Street building society, where she answers letters addressed to the famous detective, Sherlock Holmes. Her curiosity is sparked when she receives an urgent telegram concerning the troubles of the celebrated author Philip St John, leading her to the mysterious Thurmwell Manor in Cambridgeshire.

Hepburn's writing is so enjoyable. She refines the essence of classic detective fiction with a gently modern touch, crafting a story that feels both nostalgic and modern. The atmospheric backdrop of the foggy fens and the gothic manor house adds a wonderfully eerie element and reminds me of a Sherlock Holmes tale (a la Hound of the Baskervilles). The central mystery is cleverly plotted, filled with twists and surprises that will keep you guessing. Hepburn adeptly weaves together various plot threads, including nods to earlier cases and hints at exciting future escapades. She also includes a compelling personal journey for the main character, full of its own twists.

The heart of the book is Harry herself. She is clever, independent, and ahead of her time - but not out of place. Her determination to solve the case, despite the societal norms of her time (without unrealistically disrespecting them), shows a clever mind indeed. The supporting characters are also well-developed, especially Oliver who is a great partner in justice (Do I ship her and Oliver? Absolutely I do, even though there is no actual romance indicated).

“The Cursed Writer” is a wonderful choice for fans of cosy and historical mysteries, and Sherlock Holmes or Agatha Christie fans. It is a delightful mix of period details, engaging characters, and a classic mystery that will attract readers who appreciate a thoughtful challenge with a hint of the supernatural. Whether you're jumping into the series for the first time or coming back for another adventure, this book is for you.

Thank you to Boldwood Books & Net Galley for a eARC in exchange for my honest review.