The Other Talmud the Yerushalmi: Unlocking the Secrets Of the Talmud of Israel for Judaism Today

The Other Talmud the Yerushalmi

Unlocking the Secrets Of the Talmud of Israel for Judaism Today

2012

Ratings1

Average rating3

15

I appreciate what R'Abrams is trying to do: show Judaism as a more flexible religion, in which decisions were made as much for historical reasons as religious ones. But this book is kind of a literary failure. R'Abrams gets so deep in her movie analogies (most of which didn't age well), that I had to google movies I'd never seen to understand her point at times. I found them jarring, unignorable and completely disruptive to the flow.

Looking past the bulky cinematic digressions, The Other Talmud also struggles with just being a massive stretch at times. R'Abrams argues the Yerushalmi had more roles for women and was in general more liberal, but I think she's cherry-picking. I haven't read much of Bavli: just daf yomi for ~6 months, so 1/15th of it, but I could find lines from the Bavli, too, to make many of the same points. I think this was a good idea, poorly executed. 2.5 stars.

March 24, 2020