When We Believed in Mermaids

4.5 stars - I can easily see why this has made it onto lots of “must read” lists - it's the perfect blend of escapist tale (exotic New Zealand), family secrets (boy, what an engaging and fascinating back story these sisters have) and romance. Well written, true emotional resonance, touching family saga, hell of an initial hook. What stopped it from being five stars for me was the fact that both sisters were fabulously beautiful and both their love interests were not only drop-dead gorgeous, but wealthy and famous as well. I like my characters a bit more true-to-life but I do understand the appeal. The ending was perfect.