Ananda Teguh
Laut bercerita novel sejarah tapi disensorkan dengan sedikit fiksi. Gaya penulisan yang indah tapi sangat telanjang dan jujur setiap bacaannya. Kepada mereka yang dihilangkan dan tetap hidup selamanya.
Charles Dickens' “Oliver Twist,” while acknowledged as a classic, presents some challenges for the modern reader. The lengthy and meandering plot can feel excessive at times, with details that may not resonate with contemporary sensibilities. Although the mystery surrounding Oliver's origins and the intrigue that surrounds him are engaging, the novel's exploration of social themes feels less relevant in today's social context.
Some noticeable weaknesses include:
* Pacing: The plot unfolds slowly, with certain sections feeling drawn out before reaching the main conflict.
* Plot holes: Though eventually addressed, the abundance of plot holes early in the story can disrupt the flow and create confusion.
* Relevance: Dickens' social critique of poverty and injustice in the Victorian era, while significant in its time, may hold less impact for modern readers living in a different social context.
However, the novel also possesses several strengths, such as:
* Plot twists: The revelations towards the end are quite surprising and provide a new perspective on previous events.
* Character development: Certain characters, particularly Oliver and Nancy, are portrayed with complexity and undergo significant development.
* Writing style: Dickens' distinctive writing style, with its use of satire and dark humor, remains engaging.
Overall, “Oliver Twist” is a novel of significant historical value, but its relevance and effectiveness as social commentary may be questioned by modern readers. Despite some weaknesses in plot and pacing, the novel still offers an engaging reading experience with surprising twists and memorable characters.