 Dark Horses
| 4 | - |
 Body of Stars
| 4 | - |
 The Lost Apothecary
| 3.34 | - |
 American Psycho
| 3.61 | 1 |
 Haunted
| 3.32 | - |
 Madam
| 3 | - |
 The Sun and Her Flowers
| 3.75 | - |
 The Hidden Witch: A Graphic Novel
| 4.15 | - |
 What Big Teeth
| 2.72 | - |
 The Haunting
| 0 | - |
 The Woman in Cabin 10
| 3.51 | - |
 The October Country
| 3.97 | - |
 The Dead Hours of Night
| 0 | - |
 True Crime
| 3.87 | 3 |
 Daughters of Jubilation
| 0 | - |
 Survive the Night
| 3.31 | - |
 Ring Shout
| 4.05 | - |
 December Park
| 3.33 | - |
 Voices in the Snow
| 3.82 | - |
 When No One is Watching
| 3.62 | - |
 Depraved
| 3.5 | - |
 The Devil Makes Three
| 2.92 | - |
 Bone White
| 3.43 | - |
 Burn the Dark
| 3 | - |
 The Hellbound Heart
| 3.9 | - |
 Penpal
| 3.97 | - |
 Rise Sister Rise
| 0 | - |
 Uncle Montague's Tales of Terror
| 3.67 | - |
 The Once and Future Witches
| 4.12 | - |
 Horror Stories to Ruin Christmas Horror Stories to Ruin Christmas: Serenity Falls Forever
| 4 | - |
 Meddling Kids
| 3.61 | - |
 The Grip of It
| 3.5 | - |
 Exquisite Corpse
| 3.67 | 3 |
 A Grimoire Dark A Grimoire Dark
| 0 | - |
 Come Closer
| 3.71 | - |
 The Boatman's Daughter
| 3.17 | - |
The Folcroft Ghosts The Folcroft Ghosts
| 3.5 | - |
 The Vampire Vampire
| 0 | - |
 Calling the Spirits
| 4 | - |
My Pretties My Pretties
| 4 | - |
 The Twisted Ones
| 3.77 | - |
 Dead Awake
| 3 | - |
 Burning Girls
| 4.1 | - |
 The Haunting of Blackwood House
| 3.04 | - |
 The Rules of Magic
| 3.73 | 3 |
 The Haunting of Rookward House
| 3.58 | - |
 The Haunting of Gillespie House
| 2.9 | - |
 Twelve Nights at Rotter House
| 2.95 | - |
 The Graveyard Apartment
| 2.5 | - |
 Roald Dahl's Book of Ghost Stories | 3.29 | - |
 Small Spaces
| 3.93 | - |
 These Witches Don't Burn
| 3.58 | - |
 A House of Ghosts A House of Ghosts
| 3.8 | - |
 The Carrow Haunt
| 3.56 | - |
 Craven Manor
| 3.5 | - |
 Dead Voices
| 3.86 | - |
 Hex
| 3.53 | - |
 The Girl from the Well
| 3.9 | - |
 The Fog
| 3.56 | - |
 The Midnight Library
| 3.84 | - |
 Beyond the Woods: Fairy Tales Retold | 5 | - |
 Venus in the Blind Spot
| 3.8 | 5 |
 When God Was a Woman
| 4.67 | - |
 The Shuddering
| 3.64 | - |
 The Haunting of Ashburn House
| 3.84 | - |
 The Rats
| 3.5 | - |
 Shiver
| 4.32 | 5 |
 Literary Witches
| 4.25 | - |
 The Witches of New York
| 3.88 | - |
 Sunflower Sisters
| 3.5 | - |
 Behind Closed Doors
| 3.76 | - |
 The Peculiar Poetories The Peculiar Poetories
| 0 | - |
 An Anomaly In Space
| 0 | - |
 The 25th Key The 25th Key
| 0 | - |
Blissful Books & Beasts Beneath Blissful Books & Beasts Beneath
| 0 | - |
Northern Frights Northern Frights
| 0 | - |
Were Wildflowers Freakin' Flourish Were Wildflowers Freakin' Flourish
| 0 | - |
Not Juss Another Oracle Book Not Juss Another Oracle Book
| 0 | - |
 Fledgling
| 3.65 | - |
 The Hate U Give
| 4.5 | - |
 The Graveyard Book
| 4.17 | - |
 The Turn of the Screw
| 3.31 | - |
 Certain Dark Things
| 3.71 | 1 |
 The Vine Witch
| 3.59 | - |
 Later
| 3.76 | - |
 The Children God Forgot The Children God Forgot
| 4 | - |
 The Broken Girls
| 4 | - |
 Whisper Down the Lane
| 3.73 | 4 |
 Payback Is a Witch
| 0 | - |
 The Creepypasta Collection: Modern Urban Legends You Can't Unread | 4.75 | - |
 Someone We Know
| 3.46 | - |
 The Creepypasta Collection Presents: Voices in the Spirit Box by Michael Marks
| 0 | - |
 The Creepypasta Collection, Volume 2: 20 Stories. No Sleep.
| 0 | - |
 Come with Me
| 4 | - |
 We Have Always Lived in the Castle
| 4.03 | - |
 A Head Full of Ghosts
| 3.86 | - |
A Bright Enchanted Suffering A Bright Enchanted Suffering
| 0 | - |
 My Heart Is a Chainsaw
| 3.68 | 5 |
 Anya's Ghost
| 3.52 | - |
 The Mary Shelley Club
| 3.62 | - |
