Sammy

I didn't hate this... but I won't be continuing the series. I couldn't get past contradictions in the plot (ex. Morgan knowing her mother was taking the same “medicine” she was fairly early in the book then was later told this information by her uncle) and the numerous references to Morgan's hair (and how it made her different/ugly/stand out/etc.).

I really enjoyed this book! Normally I don't vibe with books that change POV - it's not always done well or in a way that flows - but this was a fresh change of pace.

Additionally, Emily's character kept me guessing and I wasn't 100% sure she'd end up on the right side of history.

I'm excited to see what else this author will bring to the table and definitely recommend giving it a go.

If you like bad fanfiction, this one's for you. Spoilers tag just in case.

Okay, here's my issues:
1. The writing felt repetitive and a little lazy. For example, every time Feyre is scared, she gets “watery bowels” and I'm sure I'd want to shit my pants too but fear responses aren't the same every single time.
2. The entire love story felt like manipulation - which was briefly touched upon in the book. I wish this was explored further.
3. Literally every male character is a walking cargo ship filled with red flags. I understand that's supposed to be part of the appeal but I just wasn't sold on it.
4. Some things just lined up too well for Feyre. Sure, there's going to be one or two “right place, right time” moments but, until she faced the challenges at the end, it seemed too easy. Like it was almost forced.
5. Because things seemed to go too well, the plot felt off. And I can forgive a poor plot if the book is spicy but that also felt... lacking.

I realize I'm in the minority here as far as opinions of this book goes, but this felt like watching a bad, slow train wreck. I plan on starting the second book to see if there's growth or changes but if this is how Maas writes, I will probably DNF the series.

I had a harder time getting through book two and found myself skimming sections. Seraphena's thoughts were exhausting - leaving you stuck in a state of emotional whiplash. Especially taking into consideration how much - or how little - time has passed. Definitely not my favorite read. Feeling hesitant about picking up book three. Might have to read something else in between.

That said, this line appears about 97% of the way in and made me laugh out loud:

“‘Most of them. Yeah. What?' He snorted. ‘You look surprised. Come now, you've met a few of them.' He shook his head. ‘You've seen firsthand how fucking annoying most of them are.'
Well, I couldn't argue with that, but...”

I originally watched the movie based on this book years ago and loved it - finally got around to reading the book and am left kind of disappointed. The chapters where Odd visits his parents felt wholly unnecessary (unless I'm just not comprehending something??) and threw me off of what was happening.

I doubt I will continue with this series.