Bark of Night

This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
—
I know it's practically de rigueur for me to start off talking about how difficult it is to talk about yet another Andy Carpenter book, but I'm going to try to resist this time (no promises that I won't resort to it next time).

Instead, I want to focus on people who read this blog and haven't picked up a book in this series – let's see if I can help you come to the light. Andy Carpenter is a defense attorney – thanks to some high profile cases, some lucrative lawsuits, (and some other things), he's an independently wealthy defense attorney (see the first couple of books for details). He's also lazy. These two traits generate a lawyer/protagonist who doesn't want to take on clients who doesn't want to go to work (he's the anti-Lincoln Lawyer). He'd rather watch sports, hang out with his wife, kid, friends and dog (especially the latter) and maybe check-in on the dog rescue he runs with a former client. He only takes on a case when he likes the potential client, he feels an injustice is being done, his wife talks him into it – or the life of a dog lies in the balance (there's a strong link between the first reason I listed and the last). This time out, it's pretty much a combination of those motivations. Nevertheless, when he takes on a client, he pulls out all the stops for him or her. Much like with Perry Mason, you have to wonder why prosecutor's don't just drop charges when Andy shows up in court – you can bet his client will be exonerated.

Andy's vet calls him to his office to talk about something – namely, this dog that had been brought in to be euthanized. Before he did that, someone in his office scanned the microchip in the dog. The man who paid for the euthanization, wasn't the owner f the dog – because he'd been murdered shortly before the dog appeared. After some digging, Andy discovers that the man who brought the dog in is very likely connected to the murder (especially when they look at his rap sheet). No one's sure why he wanted a vet to take care of destroying the dog rather than doing it himself. But someone completely different has been charged with the crime, and Andy knows that this man is innocent – he has to be, there's no other explanation how the would-be dog killer got involved.

From there, Andy and his team (his PI wife, her PI friend/Andy's bodyguard, Andy's CPA/hacker, his associate attorney) set out to defend their client, figure out why anyone would want to kill the victim (a documentary filmmaker, and not a particularly successful – or good – one), and maybe answer a few questions about the victim's dog. Like most Carpenter novels, the mystery is just twisty enough to keep you guessing to the end. Andy's courtroom antics are pretty subdued this time, but watching him in action is fun – particularly as he battles the Assistant D.A.

Andy's team – and his friends who aren't on the team – are as enjoyable to spend time with as ever. With some long-running series you stick with it because the characters are so near and dear to you. With some, you put up with characters because the author puts out great mysteries/adventures/whatever. It's with the best series that you get both – a good mystery (in this case) and a cast of characters you look forward to seeing again. That's definitely what we have in the Andy Carpenter books, and Bark of Night is a prime example of it.

As a capper, if the last few paragraphs don't provoke a warm fuzzy or three in you, there's something wrong with you and you should probably seek professional help. Rosenfelt is good at the heart-warming stuff, and he's at the top of his game here.

Newcomers will get enough information along the way to hop on board here – there's no need to feel like you need to go back to Book One (Open and Shut) and read them in order to catch all the nuance. Start here, and you'll easily see why this book has charmed and entertained audiences enough to last for 19 books (and counting!). It's a clever mystery, featuring characters that are reliably comfortable and funny – with just enough moments of seriousness and displays of skill that you can believe they'll be defending someone and bringing a killer to justice at the same time. This is one of the better installments in the last few years (both for being enjoyable and for the mystery) and should move right to the top of your TBR (note that a “lesser” Andy Carpenter book is still fun, engaging and entertaining).


Disclaimer: I received this eARC from St. Martin's Press via NetGalley in exchange for this post – thanks to both for this opportunity.