Ratings61
Average rating3.9
Murder investigation | Totalitarian regime
I had to constantly remind myself that this is not a dystopian fiction. Inspired by a real-life investigation, it is set in the USSR under the rule of Stalin – Moscow, 1953.
The story follows Leo Demidov, a high-ranking State Security operative, a believer. The politics of that time is portrayed in the most not boring way possible in the first few chapters. As Leo is forced to investigate an officer's son's death on the railway track which has been reported as an accidental death, he notices something off. To disregard an official report is not an easy task for Leo. He is a believer. A believer in the party, a believer in the society the leaders have formed. In this society there is no crime. To believe that a murder has occurred is to have lost faith. That is blasphemy. “An elaborate charade that fools no one”
There is constant threat to life looming over every citizen's head, as soon as they are twelve years of age. Children are obedient, adults are law abiding, everyone is wary, like prey in a forest. There is no forgiveness, no trust. And it is imperative to catch one spy even if it costs innocent lives. There is a uniform love for the leader in all – children and adults, officials and housewives. It is an unusual combination of fear and pride. Or more likely it is just fear masquerading. It is an unforgiving story and pulls no punches. The reality must have been equally horrifying if not worse. A gripping story, each sentence pulling my eyes to the next.
As the story moves forward and when the façade unravels before Leo's eyes, the hunter becomes the hunted. On realizing that public opinion as well as law is not on the side of truth, but on the side of the Party, Leo is forced to embark on his mission to solve a string of child murders, with only his wife by his side; and even that relationship is hanging by a thread.
There is a calmness to the brutality in the story. It comes unexpected and makes the least noise. The act of violence is never elaborated. There are never descriptions of murder dragged out. All quick and efficient like any job well done, a routine – nothing to be made a fuss about. This further adds to the bleakness of the environment.
The colors in a book sets a mood. What are the colors in this book? There is bright red, excessively red, a little too much just to be safe. The is red on the white snow. There is grey in the sky and dark brown bark in the mouths of dead little children.
It would be a shame for you to miss this book.
I really liked the way the author brought the terrors of Stalinist Russia to life. The fear, the resignation, the apathy. Well researched. The story itself was not so much to my liking, but interesting enough to keep me reading on. The characters seemed pretty real with their own agendas and motivations. What bugged me was that we didn't get to know what Vasili's personal problem with Leo was. Was it purely a competition thing? Or a way to show his obsessive and psychotic character? The transformation of Leo was nicely done, didn't seem too far fetched and was neatly explained by his tendency to selective perception through his childhood experience. All in all a good read with vivid descriptions, but I would have wished for a stronger crime story.
https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/3920693-richard-reviles-censorship-always-in-all-ways said, “Tom Rob Smith wrote this awful book about awful people doing awful things in an awful country to amuse and entertain us.” This review says it all. But, in case you want to know my personal feelings, I will briefly indulge you. First, this is a truly grizzly subject matter. I have a propensity for the darker side of fiction and this certainly did not fail. Those who chalk this up as a thriller or a crime novel will get their money's worth. Second, some people in the Goodreads world have added this book to lists reserved for spies and agents of espionage. Leo is an officer in the Soviet State Security (MGB). The Stalinist nation lived in constant fear of punishment for being associated, even by rumor, with anti-Soviet sentiment. His position and cultural norms do not qualify this book as having anything to do with spies or espionage. Needless to say, when I was not met with any of the aforementioned subject matter, I was a little upset. If you're looking for spies, just re-read [b:Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy 18989 Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy John le Carré https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1327889127s/18989.jpg 2491780].
Nell'unione sovietica di Stalin, il crimine non può esistere. Dunque non può esserci anche un distretto di polizia che se ne occupa; i delitti semplicemente non avvengono. Ora però dei bambini cominciano a morire. Contro le istituzioni in cui ha sempre creduto e difeso e che lo hanno trasformato come uomo, Leo decide lo stesso di investigare contro tutti, anche con chi gli sta vicino.
Una bellissima sorpresa questo libro di Tom Rob Smith, un grande esordio da cui sarà tratto un film che sperò colga appieno tutte le sfumature di questo romanzo, che non è solo thriller ma anche una ricostruzione storica dettagliata degli avvenimenti e della vita nella Russia degli anni 50 a cavallo della morte di Stalin e dei suoi anni di terrore.
La narrazione è vibrante, veloce, tesa e con vari colpi di scena che accompagnano il lettore per tutta la storia.
Un bellissimo romanzo che mette a nudo le anime degli uomini costretti a “sopravvivere” in determinate situazioni. Rende bene l'asfissia del Pensiero di Stato. Bella la storia, bella l'ambientazione. Personaggi solidi e ben costruiti, risulta particolarmente sorprendente che si tratti di un'opera prima. Colpisce l'ingegnoso colpo di scena finale.
Lo consiglio caldamente a tutti e per quanto mi riguarda non resta che attendere il prossimo.
Child murders are grim enough, but when set against a very stark, very real Stalinist Russia where even spouses can denounce (and send to their death) each other, it makes for a novel that is not for the faint of heart. Yet, the story of Leo Dimidev, one of Stalin's secret policemen, as he tries to find the truth about a serial killer in a society that doesn't want to acknowledge such crimes, is a story of redemption. The characters are full-fledged and nuanced, the narrative tautly paced. This is a thriller with its share of surprises, not the least of which is how redemption and some level of optimism is found in such a grim, dangerous place.