Darling Girl

I enjoyed reading this and its take on Peter Pan. I was disappointed in the way the ending was presented and felt that the stakes could have been higher with better payoffs. It was almost there.

I went in blind. Two or three chapters in, I was hooked on the dark fairy tale vibes but by chapter 10, I was bored. This is an incredibly average book and even the trigger warning scenes (that if I had known about prior would have made me skip the book all together) were shockingly boring. It's like the author thought throwing in some trauma would make up for the poorly written characters.

A lot of the plot wasn't even resolved. The ending was lazy as hell (the main character gets drugged while her mom does all the hard work) and then her company gets sold for enough money that she never has to work again, her son is magically healed and she falls in love. This feels like an unfinished project and it's seriously made me consider cancelling my BOTM subscription all together since they thought this was good enough to promote.

I swear this was a rape fantasy draft that got picked up by someone who knew someone. Don't waste your time ☺️

I've always loved the story of Peter Pan. The idea of being whisked away to another world? Even as someone who doesn't often care for fantasy, I'm enchanted by every production and adaption I've seen. As far as retellings go, I didn't think anything would top the movie ‘Hook'. How wrong I was!

I read every word of this book meticulously I was so absorbed. I took my time trying to savor every second while simultaneously having trouble putting it down. The new dynamics presented here have assured that I will never look at this tale the same way again. I'm oddly okay with it. Hearing that Peter Pan was the villain was what made me pick up this book in the first place. 

I wasn't sure how I would like Holly at first. While she does so much for her kids, there is a selfish air about her. That bothered me less as the story went on and the character growth feels authentic and genuine. I loved the involvement of Jane as well. Jack and Eden are lovely additions to the Darling family. And Christopher? Oh, I do hope we will get a sequel/prequel with him in the future. 

I could gush about so much but for fear of spoilers, I'll end by saying that I thoroughly enjoyed this story. There are some loose ends that I would have liked to have been tied up, but perhaps that was intentional...

Thanks to NetGalley and Dutton for providing me with a free ARC copy in exchange for my honest review. 

This book was slow. It stunted my reading plans for this month. It's definitely more mystery than fantasy. So many bad things just kept happening in a row that I didn't want to keep reading. The resolution was good enough, but I hated how at some point during the story, you don't trust any of the characters. Yes, they all end up being good except for Peter, but still. If it were a morally gray moment, it would have been good. If I lose trust in a character, it's hard to bring it back. It was just okay.

While there was enough of a story to keep me reading, I didn't like it very much. It was an odd take on a fairytale retelling and not one I would recommend. Do not read if you like Peter Pan!

I love a dark retelling but this just missed the mark completely. It brought up alllll the triggers without any rhyme or reason and buried it in the minutia of insufferable characters.

I really liked this twist on what happens after the fairy tale. No character in this is perfect and I loved all the flaws. Got me out of the non-romance slump I've been in.