Ratings5
Average rating2.8
I just...I expected more from this book. Both in depth and page count. The overarching story is grabbing, but I felt whiplashed with each plot twist. I kept wanting to dive deeper into the many + distinct characters' backstories and psyches. For all the emotional loops and leaps, I felt this book could have been and should have been at least 100 pages to flesh out the truly unique story.
READ :: if you pride yourself in unraveling a plot within the first 100 pages and are looking for a challenge.
SKIP :: If you have a cruise vacation on deck + have been repeatedly accused of being a helicopter parent.
Once again, a novel from a “best of” list. Once I realized this wasn't meant to be a fast-paced, white knuckled thriller, I enjoyed the book more. Until I came to this insight, which was about three quarters of the way through, I kept wanting the narrative to have more twists, turns, and excitement. There is drama in the story, but it's not really in the plot points, but rather within the conflict which arises internally and externally among the characters. Yet, too much of this drama felt too tidy. It's about three families, each neatly constructed with a boy and a girl. And not to give a spoiler, but even the conclusion and the long epilogue felt too tidy as well. For a novel with a truly gut-wrenching premise and at least one agonizing scene describing about the worst thing that could befall a teen-aged girl, the conclusion wrapped things up nice and cleanly. In life, things do wrap up smoothly, but often not this perfectly.
I agree with everything Rachel Hall said in her review - lots of stereotypes, no consistent tone, totally implausible. The adults were all awful, and the plot felt pretty racist at points.