Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis
Ratings235
Average rating3.5
All Too Identifiable. Ok, so the first version of this review was basically comparing my life to Vance's as he relates in in this book, but let's face it - y'all don't care about the details there. :D Suffice it to say that as a trailer park kid from the southern Appalachian foothills outside of Atlanta, who also spent time "in the country" (though Atlanta has now fully taken over that region since my childhood) at his family's farm and who also became the first person in his immediate family to go to - and graduate from - college... yeah, there was quite a bit I could identify with in this book. There was also quite a bit where we diverged, specifically in that while the hardships Vance lived through within his own family were frequently seen in my *friends'* and *schoolmates'* and *neighbors'* lives... *very* little of it was ever as immediately in my face for me, even back in the trailer park.
I read the Audible version of this book, actually as I was driving from my home in Jacksonville, FL to my homeland north of Atlanta over the weekend, so I don't have any information about the breadth of any bibliography here. What I can say is that Vance's words, from his perspectives of his experience, ring true with my own observations and experiences in a similar-ish background, time, and region.
I can also say that Vance describes his time in the Marines much as I've seen and heard others of our generation describe them, particularly as it relates to being crystal clear that while he served in the Green Zone in Iraq, he never directly saw enemy fire or fired on the enemy.
Overall there is truly little if anything to fault here. The writing style - and reading style, in Audible form - were very easy to flow with, it is clear that Vance is actively examining his life and not simply making excuses for himself or anyone else, and in the end, again, this truly does ring all-too-true to my own observations as a contemporary in a similar ish region of the country.
Very much recommended.
Originally posted at bookanon.com.
All Too Identifiable. Ok, so the first version of this review was basically comparing my life to Vance's as he relates in in this book, but let's face it - y'all don't care about the details there. :D Suffice it to say that as a trailer park kid from the southern Appalachian foothills outside of Atlanta, who also spent time "in the country" (though Atlanta has now fully taken over that region since my childhood) at his family's farm and who also became the first person in his immediate family to go to - and graduate from - college... yeah, there was quite a bit I could identify with in this book. There was also quite a bit where we diverged, specifically in that while the hardships Vance lived through within his own family were frequently seen in my *friends'* and *schoolmates'* and *neighbors'* lives... *very* little of it was ever as immediately in my face for me, even back in the trailer park.
I read the Audible version of this book, actually as I was driving from my home in Jacksonville, FL to my homeland north of Atlanta over the weekend, so I don't have any information about the breadth of any bibliography here. What I can say is that Vance's words, from his perspectives of his experience, ring true with my own observations and experiences in a similar-ish background, time, and region.
I can also say that Vance describes his time in the Marines much as I've seen and heard others of our generation describe them, particularly as it relates to being crystal clear that while he served in the Green Zone in Iraq, he never directly saw enemy fire or fired on the enemy.
Overall there is truly little if anything to fault here. The writing style - and reading style, in Audible form - were very easy to flow with, it is clear that Vance is actively examining his life and not simply making excuses for himself or anyone else, and in the end, again, this truly does ring all-too-true to my own observations as a contemporary in a similar ish region of the country.
Very much recommended.
Originally posted at bookanon.com.
