Hood Feminism: Notes from the Women That a Movement Forgot
Ratings70
Average rating4.3
I have been very interested in reading this book since the first time I heard about it because I always want to learn more about intersectional feminism, and this turned out to be such an brilliant read that can't be forgotten easily.
It's nothing new that when we talk about mainstream feminism and see who are represented as feminist icons in the media, the image we are shown mostly is that of a cis white educated woman, and all the women of marginalized groups who are working tirelessly for their communities get sidelined. In this book, the author tries to talk extensively about various issues that disproportionately affect the Black community (mainly women) but never get talked about as important topics in the mainstream feminist circles. These are all issues that we are familiar with but the author does a great job of highlighting why they should be treated as feminist issues and how working to solve them will help women across all communities.
The chapters about hunger, poverty, homelessness, housing crisis and school to prison pipeline are harrowing to read because of the unique ways in which they effect Black women. The author rightly points out that in the wake of dwindling social safety nets and a government that treats poverty as a moral failing and not as a generational policy failure, poor Black women have to fend for themselves to ensure food and survival for their families. But when the methods they use for survival are unconventional, they are harassed and criminalized and shamed, by so called feminists and everyone else, without ever trying to examine the various factors like race, class and centuries of oppression which have to led to these circumstances. Even when Black women develop ways to cope and support themselves and their communities, they are not considered good enough because they don't fit into the box that mainstream feminism has decided.
There are also many other issues that the author talks about which uniquely affect the Black community, and are largely ignored by white feminists because they don't want to understand the intersectionality of issues - like how Black women are considered tougher and hence not considered worthy of emotional and mental support, how health issues like eating disorders go unnoticed because the bodies of Black women don't fit into some mythical white supremacist body image, how Black children are forced to grow up and never given the chance to be innocent or worthy of second chances which wildly changes the kind of parenting decisions Black women have to make, how maternal mortality and general healthcare outcomes are worse for Black women even when they advocate for themselves - these are issues that need solutions and solidarity that are specific to the Black community and mainstream white feminists have to work within the communities, be allies, form alliances, forget about respectability politics and politeness, and have to amplify the work & the voices of the activists and feminists who have been working from within the communities for long periods of time because they understand the intricacies of the issues.
To conclude, I'm sure I have missed talking about many other things that the author compellingly discusses, giving both statistics and personal anecdotes and it was such an important and eye opening read. We don't talk enough about intersectional feminism when talking about women's issues and the author rightfully points out that sometimes, feminism has to be about solving the basic needs of women and not just lofty homogeneous ideals of equality which don't actually work on the ground. I would highly recommend this book to anyone who likes reading about feminism or anyone who wants to know more about the work that is being/needs to be done in marginalized communities to solve systemic issues. What a book and I can't wait to read more by the author.
“Family, whether biological or not, is supposed to support you, but that doesn't mean no one can ever tell you that you're wrong, or that any form of critique is an attack. And yes, sometimes the words involved are harsh. But as adults, as people who are doing hard work, you cannot expect your feelings to be the center of someone else's struggle.”
An excellent critique of white-centered feminism and the feminist movement overall. I learned and shifted some thinking on many of the topics. The chapters on schools, parenting, and how we adultify young girls are particularly relevant to teachers. Stongly recommended to every adult.
I have already read this one twice. As someone who would absolutely call myself a feminist, this was a tremendous look into feminism and how it is majorly lacking in its more expansive view. This was the first book I've read from a POC on feminism and I will surely be adding more because it felt like a wake-up call from the white-centered messaging online social activism regularly feeds me.
Super interesting and educational. Found some essay's to be harder to follow but that may be a writing style thing personal to me. Would 100% still recommend
First, I want to state the obvious - I am white and maybe less obvious to the random people who will read this review, I am fairly conservative and do not consider myself a modern feminist. So, yes I knew I wasn't going to agree with this book in political terms - However, I read this to better understand the balance of feminism with class issues and ended feeling tired and frustrated.
I found the book's approach to addressing class, racism, and gender issues through the lens of feminism to be problematic. Racism happens to black women, that doesn't make it a feminist issue. There is a severe problem with lack of education in low-class areas, that doesn't mean only little girls need better access to schools. I thought this book was going to touch on how modern feminism tries overtake issues like class, race and gender - this turned out to be the exact opposite.
To be fair, I was hoping for something closer to “Invisible Women: Data Bias in a World Designed for Men” and this just missed the mark completely for me.
I wish we would stop trying to label every single movement and stop categorizing everything into “class disparities” or “race issues” or “feminist movement” and focus more on those who are suffering. We need to stop trying to define it all perfectly and focus on the people who are in pain and living as less-than - REGARDLESS OF THE REASON. Can we just treat humans better and stop arguing about who deserves it most?
Personable account of someone that lives just a few miles from me in Chicago, but has a difference journey that she shares with thought provoking perspective.
Adding this to my list of books that should be required reading
Ok editing my review after more thought: I agree with her stances and views and the fragility of white feminism. I did find the writing a bit repetitive and not fleshed out enough.
The concepts and topics in this book are so important. And I think this is a really important read for all feminists.
But I really struggled with the format. In hindsight, I think it reads more like a speech so I should have gone with the audio book.