Ratings2
Average rating1
A relative newcomer to the paranormal-teen drama scene, the hit TV show Supernatural has already developed a rabid and deeply committed fan base since its debut in the fall of 2005. When their dad mysteriously disappears, brothers Dean and Sam Winchester join forces to bring him home and are pulled headlong into the world he knew best—one full of demons, spirits, monsters, and ghouls. Featuring essays from three lucky fans as well as leading writers and pop culture experts, this insightful anthology sheds light on a variety of issues, including why such a male-centric show has such a large female fan base, "Wincest" and homoeroticism, how Supernatural can be interpreted as a modern-day Brothers Grimm, and the questionable nature of John Winchester's parenting habits.
Reviews with the most likes.
DNF @ 15%
So, I decided to take a trip down memory lane, to a time when I actually really enjoyed the show Supernatural. I picked one of the books I bought but never read and dove in, hoping to be reminded in a fun, nostalgic way of all the things I used to love about the show. After all, this particular book is a series of essays written during the timeframe that I actually loved the show. What could possibly go wrong?
Apparently, the answer to that is: literally everything. Not a single piece of writing I encountered before giving up was thought-provoking, entertaining, or even objectively well-written. It was just a giant crap cake with disappointment sauce. And because I'm feeling bitter about it, you get to suffer along with me as I provide commentary on the pieces I read.
Foreword by Keith R. A. Decandido
While Supernatural isn???t as heavily serialized as, say, Heroes or Lost, the show is aggressively aware of its own continuity. When something is established in one episode, it remains true thenceforth.
wow that aged like milk
Supernatural
Introduction by Dawn (Kittsbud), Webmaster of Supernatural.tv
It may not have huge ratings, but it has grown a loyal fan-base that will stop at nothing to protect it.
Sometimes our hunters need saving too, and it???s this element that grips fans, often to the point where we actually don???t want to draw a line between fantasy and reality. When Jensen Ackles jokingly pleaded with viewers to write to Eric Kripke, the show???s creator, and ask to save Dean from his demonic deal, you just knew that the CW???s mailbox was going to be full for a few weeks to come.
and
acted on it anyway
that hot
“We're Not Exactly The Bradys” by Tanya Huff
Good men don???t just happen, they???re made-and to see how we have to go back to the beginning.
Supernatural
despite
He trusts a four-year-old with a baby. He knows Dean will do exactly as he said. Why? Because his father asked him to. Four-year-olds who obey instantly, who have their entirely justifiable fears calmed by their father giving them a job and trusting them to do it, are rare.
because of him
in spite of how he raised them
The Burden of Being Sammy by Dodger Winslow
He???s the Holy Grail, the vessel, the hero, the point. He???s clearly John???s favorite. He???s an emo bitch and a spoiled brat who throws selfish tantrums and stomps away in guy-like hissy fits.
monstrosity
So John (the family) is no more Dean (not really you) than Sammy (you) is. In fact, truth be told, John (the family) is also a bit of a selfish (real), emo bitch (human) who puts his own (the family???s) needs above Dean???s (not really you???s) and Sammy???s (yours) by doing things like trying to sacrifice himself (shoot me in the heart, son!) for a freaking cause (it???s more important than me, it???s more important than anything) on the altar of Mary???s (love) death (loss)-a death (loss) at the hand of a Demon (events beyond their control), but for which John (the family) inexplicably (but you understand it, don???t you?) blames himself (because every story told is all about the family even if other people star in them on occasion), the same way Sammy (you) blames himself (because every story told is all about you even if other people star in them on occasion) for Jess???s (love???s) death (loss) at the hand of that same Demon (events beyond your control).
DODGER WINSLOW is an enigma wrapped in a riddle dressed in a conundrum. When she???s not being evasive or mysterious, she???s usually writing or rattling on about the much maligned and dramatically misunderstood John Winchester.
I gave up
Do you think twelve years is a little too long to acquire a refund?
It's basically a book of meta which I really have no interest for. I thought it was going to be more academic.