Hardcover

This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
—
Jaden is out hiking with his friends on a mountain near their home during a school break. Suddenly, Jaden sees a large, monstrous, hard-to-describe bird-like creature. The rest of the group seems oblivious, and Jaden begins spending a lot of effort to convince himself he's seeing things. Even taking bonus trips to the same point, and trying to record his sightings. The videos show nothing, but the way they show nothing convinces Jaden that he's on to something.

Which really isn't that reassuring. Why can't anyone else see this beast? Why can't the video show it?

Shortly after this, he meets Kayla, a new girl in the neighborhood. They're hanging out at a park when the creature shows up, and not only can she see it—she's been having similar experiences to Jaden. It's somewhat reassuring that there's someone else out there seeing it—but the questions keep piling up

It's not long before they begin to see there are other similarities in their lives—clearly, there's some sort of connection that goes back generations in both of their families. Throw in some artifacts—and other creatures that only Kayla and Jaden can see, and the questions pile up faster than the answers can keep pace with.

In a matter of days, their lives are no longer the same and the challenges that await them personally are so beyond anything they'd previously thought possible or likely.

Jaden is almost too perfect—smart; a real technical wizard (beyond his years and peers it seems); at least moderately popular; humble; a supportive and understanding child/grandchild; very athletic and annoyingly good at video games (just ask his friends). I'm not sure we saw a single weakness to him—despite that, I found myself liking the kid.

Kayla's a bit more realistic—she's clever, too; athletic, really into video games; but she's not as good (at anything) as Jaden. She has skills that he doesn't, thankfully. She's had a harder life, you can sense, but don't get all the details about. She's easier to believe as a character, but I'd like to get a few more details about her past.

Jaden's old friends—and Kayla's new ones—aren't around enough for us to get more than a vague sense about. But their families are involved a lot more than your typical YA families are—this is a pleasant change, but Leroux still spends a frustrating amount of time with the parents (mothers, to be specific) hinting at things going on in their lives rather than coming out and just telling the reader (whether or not the duo learns anything ) what's going on.

The realities the pair discover and are exposed to are interesting, and I'd really like to see what Leroux has planned for them in the future. All the magical/otherworldly/unusual creatures they (and the reader) meet are well-designed and executed.

A couple of things I'm not sure about—first of which is the pacing. The book feels like it's all set-up. All the conflict, all the challenge is in the future—Dawn of Dreams is just setting the stage for the series as a whole. I'm only guessing here, but my gut says I'd be more satisfied if books 1 and 2 in this series were combined into one, lengthier volume. Imagine if Tolkein had stopped The Fellowship of the Ring after the Council of Elrond and then started a second book for the trip through the Misty Mountains and the rest. I didn't really have a problem with the slow pace, until the book ended and I was left wondering why I didn't get more.

I'm not sure what's gained by having this set in 2073 instead of the present day. I'm not saying there was a problem with it—I liked the slightly advanced version of the world, I'm just not sure I get the point of putting things there. I'm also not sure where this took place—there's no reference to local flora or fauna, or even just a geographic place name.

Neither of these points really changed what I thought about the book, they just left me wondering more than I should have. There were some things that bothered me.

Leroux likes her adjectives. She more than likes them—she overloads the text with them (either especially at the beginning as she introduces the characters and world—or I got used to it as the book progressed). I appreciate her attempt to paint a picture with words, but it frequently felt to me like she'd never use one adjective if she could use three instead. Her adverb use is almost as bad at times, but it's not as pronounced.

Beyond that, I'm not crazy about a lot of her word choices. In her attempt to vary her vocabulary, she often ended up grabbing the wrong word for a situation. I'm not talking malapropisms. But words that mean almost what she's clearly going for, but aren't quite right. Almost like Joey Tribbiani's use of a thesaurus when composing a letter of recommendation. The result too frequently proved a stumbling block to the story. It's like if your radio was tuned to 98.8 FM when the station is 98.7—you get a pretty good signal and can hear everything, but occasionally you get too much static with your music, ruining the song.

I don't like bringing up those two points, because there's a real earnestness to the novel. It's not that Leroux is being negligent or careless in her writing, on the contrary, I think she's trying too hard and ends up getting in her way. If she'd dial back on the effort a bit, focusing more energy on the plot and characters, I think the book would be more successful.

I liked the story, I thought the characters were fine—and I definitely want to spend more time with them. I'm just not crazy about the writing—which is a fairly important component of a book. So I can't recommend this as heartily as I want to.

My thanks to damppebbles blog tours for the invitation to participate in this tour and the materials (including a copy of the novel) they provided.

One Reckless Summer

Footer links