The Banned Books Club
Ratings1
Average rating5
*Almost* Deceptive Marketing. This is one of those books where the title has *just* enough to do with the book itself that it isn't *actually* deceptive marketing... but you can look to the lower starred reviews and see that many readers felt that the title and book had little to do with each other. (And they're right.) There is really nothing in this tale about banning books or anything related to the topic, other than a sentence or two of setup that is also (currently, as of publication day) in the description of the book.
Instead, the tale we *actually* get is a version of the Prodigal Son. One sister left years ago after having her world shattered in HS, the other sister stayed in their hometown and has now been taking care of their mother as her mother's health rapidly fails. As mom's time is nearing its end, the prodigal sister is convinced to return... and now, *everyone* in town is going to have to come to terms with the fallout from all those years ago.
In the process, we get a lot of different things, some discussed more than others - spousal abuse/ controlling spouse, sexual harassment/ teen molestation (to be clear, the age of the student in question is *not* "child molestation" in all States), breast cancer, coming home, uncovering family secrets, really quite a bit, such that even in a 350 ish page book... like I said, not all of it is covered n much depth.
And of course we also get a romance plot here... and maybe more... because, well, why not? ;)
Overall, for what it *actually* is, this tale is actually quite strong in many ways. Yes, it has its weaknesses at times, but I think overall this ultimately comes out on the stronger side of resiliency and overcoming your demons. But this is also a tale where your mileage truly will vary, so give it a read and make your own call.
Very much recommended.
Originally posted at bookanon.com.
*Almost* Deceptive Marketing. This is one of those books where the title has *just* enough to do with the book itself that it isn't *actually* deceptive marketing... but you can look to the lower starred reviews and see that many readers felt that the title and book had little to do with each other. (And they're right.) There is really nothing in this tale about banning books or anything related to the topic, other than a sentence or two of setup that is also (currently, as of publication day) in the description of the book.
Instead, the tale we *actually* get is a version of the Prodigal Son. One sister left years ago after having her world shattered in HS, the other sister stayed in their hometown and has now been taking care of their mother as her mother's health rapidly fails. As mom's time is nearing its end, the prodigal sister is convinced to return... and now, *everyone* in town is going to have to come to terms with the fallout from all those years ago.
In the process, we get a lot of different things, some discussed more than others - spousal abuse/ controlling spouse, sexual harassment/ teen molestation (to be clear, the age of the student in question is *not* "child molestation" in all States), breast cancer, coming home, uncovering family secrets, really quite a bit, such that even in a 350 ish page book... like I said, not all of it is covered n much depth.
And of course we also get a romance plot here... and maybe more... because, well, why not? ;)
Overall, for what it *actually* is, this tale is actually quite strong in many ways. Yes, it has its weaknesses at times, but I think overall this ultimately comes out on the stronger side of resiliency and overcoming your demons. But this is also a tale where your mileage truly will vary, so give it a read and make your own call.
Very much recommended.
Originally posted at bookanon.com.
