The Crimson Legion

Averages out to two stars for me. On the one hand, great flavour and lore, on the other, rather unrealistic action.

I didn't really like any of the characters in the first book. In this one, they are either more of the same or worse. Rikus was definitely worse. I don't see how he can inspire confidence and leadership when he all does is improvise and turning out lucky. He's overconfident, arrogant, and completely tactless. But at least there was a point I guess, right at the end you'll see why.

What I didn't like about the battles is that they are completely unrealistic. Food and water were only used as plot mechanics as opposed to being essential in a military campaign out in the desert. There's no strategy to speak of yet trained soldiers fall like wheat to the scythe - completely ineffective against Tyr's gladiators, which doesn't really make sense. Gladiators are great at duels and skirmishes, but they should not be able to bulldoze soldiers in large-scale battles where tactics and discipline are crucial.

I did like the side story regarding the lore of the dwarves and getting to see another of Athas' city and sorcerer-king. I guess this is the set up to the next book. I'll be happy to get back to just focusing on things on the smaller scale.