The Devil and the Dark Water

I don't know how to feel.
- I didn't guess the ending twist
- i loves the similarities and commentary on sherlock and watson
- the writing was impeccable
- i kept wanting to pick it back up and finish it
- it was so good it got me to annotate
But for some reason i didn't love it
I think it's because of the ending. I don't like how it eneded. The author was happy with it and its not a bad ending but it wasn't satisfying for me. I'm sorry but it felt slightly out of character and unrealistic for that character. It felt out of his moral compass or that he would've had to wrestle with it more before agreeing. Anywayssss I enjoyed the journey but the ending fell flat for me