The doubt factory

Originally posted at Fantasy Literature: http://www.fantasyliterature.com/reviews/the-doubt-factory/

Paolo Bacigalupi???s most recent stand-alone novel is a modern day young adult thriller. It???s about a rich girl named Alix who attends an elite highschool (uh oh, it???s already starting off wrong for me) who meets a mysterious sexy bad boy (oh gosh) who leads a diverse gang of socially conscious teenage vandals (ugh) who hope to change the world by taking down a public relations company that works for industries like Big Pharma. They hope to do this by stalking Alix and showing her how bad her father, one of the owners of the company, is.

At first Alix, after she finally figures out what the mystery stalker is all about, isn???t willing to believe that her father, a man who takes such good care of his family, could be so cold-hearted toward the rest of the world. Ah, but Alix has the hots for the sexy bad boy stalker (it wouldn???t be a YA novel otherwise), so she begins to investigate his claim. Could her awesome father be such a villain? And, if so, should she blow the whistle?

Up to this point I have loved everything I???ve read by Paolo Bacigalupi. His excellent story collection Pump Six and Other Stories is one of my favorite collections because it???s full of unique and fascinating stories. The Doubt Factory, on the other hand, doesn???t live up to my expectations because of its clich??d YA tropes and its heavy-handed message. However, it???s exciting and I may still find myself recommending the book to my Research Methods students because it sheds light on important issues that I care and teach about: how industries such as Big Pharma are able to confuse ???truth??? in such a way as to either get dangerous products on the market or delay getting them removed. Sometimes they use shoddy research techniques, biased reporting, shameless lobbying and deceitful advertising, all to make money off an ignorant populace. All they have to do, as the title of Bacigalupi???s book suggests, is to create doubt. The people who do this may be very nice people who are just doing what their job requires. Bacigalupi asks at what point we should hold them personally accountable and shows us that even a teenage girl can make a difference.

I like this message, but wish it had been delivered with more nuance. After finishing The Doubt Factory, I had learned something, but I felt like I???d been flattened with a steamroller. And I definitely could have done without all the icky teenage stalker bits. Alix lets the stalker into her house at night, goes to meet him in an abandoned factory, gets in his car, and other things???. I thought she was stupid. Meanwhile Sexy Stalker thinks she???s amazing, not a ???sheep??? like all the other girls, and that she???s going to change the world. His evidence is that when confronted with the news about her father, she starts Googling to find out the truth. I feel like Bacigalupi doesn???t give teenage girls enough credit if he thinks that???s all it takes to make a girl stand out from the crowd.

So, while I appreciated Bacigalupi???s Message, and while I admit that the story will be educational and probably thrilling for most teenage readers, I wished for less typical YA drama and more subtlety. I may recommend the book to my students because of the Message about research ethics, but not to my kids because sleeping with your stalker just isn???t cool.

I listened to Listening Library???s audio version of The Doubt Factory which is 12 hours long and read by Emma Galvin. Ms Galvin gave a terrific performance. Her voices and pacing were excellent. If you plan to read The Doubt Factory, I recommend this version.

My reaction after finishing this book: Sooooo what the heck was that?

I have been a fan of Bacigalupi's work ever since I read Ship Breaker and The Drowned Cities . I loved how both of those novels took the dystopias that we had all seen before and managed to make them the darker and grittier versions that I think made them fresh and new. So when I saw The Doubt Factory at my local library, I could not help but pick it up and begin reading it. I didn't care that I had a low rating on Goodreads, after all, so did the other two books I'd read by him, and I loved them. Sadly, this is one of those times where the majority is correct. This book is a run of the mill thriller with cardboard characters and a creepy romance that makes me wonder why the author thought this was a good idea to begin with.

Let's start with the plot of the novel: it is about a cliche and boring as you'd expect it to be. Every twist and turn that was there I saw coming pages ahead, and it ends exactly how you think it ends. If you've read or seen any TV show or film with a similar premise, then you will be able to figure it out too. This is just sad because I really felt like this could have been something actually good, with a commentary on how companies and scientific studies actually do put out conflicting studies related to health and wellness products. However, here it is delivered in such a harsh manner that I cannot believe that this was written by the same author as the other books I read and loved. Ultimately, this book was just predictable plot wise.

Then there is the romance. I will say this, I have never found a story I like where the main character is supposed to fall in love with the creepy stalker. Instead, I usually find them unbelievable and just stupid. This novel does nothing to change my mind.

In the end, there is nothing of value here worth reading. I am still going to check out his other books, but I think that this is one you should skip. I give it a two out of five.