From the Frontier to the Border Wall in the Mind of America
WINNER OF THE PULITZER PRIZE A new and eye-opening interpretation of the meaning of the frontier, from early westward expansion to Trump’s border wall. Ever since this nation’s inception, the idea of an open and ever-expanding frontier has been central to American identity. Symbolizing a future of endless promise, it was the foundation of the United States’ belief in itself as an exceptional nation – democratic, individualistic, forward-looking. Today, though, America hasa new symbol: the border wall. In The End of the Myth, acclaimed historian Greg Grandin explores the meaning of the frontier throughout the full sweep of U.S. history – from the American Revolution to the War of 1898, the New Deal to the election of 2016. For centuries, he shows, America’s constant expansion – fighting wars and opening markets – served as a “gate of escape,” helping to deflect domestic political and economic conflicts outward. But this deflection meant that the country’s problems, from racism to inequality, were never confronted directly. And now, the combined catastrophe of the 2008 financial meltdown and our unwinnable wars in the Middle East have slammed this gate shut, bringing political passions that had long been directed elsewhere back home. It is this new reality, Grandin says, that explains the rise of reactionary populism and racist nationalism, the extreme anger and polarization that catapulted Trump to the presidency. The border wall may or may not be built, but it will survive as a rallying point, an allegorical tombstone marking the end of American exceptionalism.
Reviews with the most likes.
I'm glad I pushed through to the end. Everything after Vietnam felt much more impactful and relevant. Reagan, Clinton, W and Obama all come out very poorly. This is not a fun read but I do feel more informed.
I read this partly for class material, and did find some good information here that I didn't know. I was especially taken with Grandin's discussion of NAFTA and the impact it had on Mexicans and American companies flooded into Mexico, displacing agricultural work there. This contributed a lot to illegal immigration to the US. I also appreciated the discussion of MLK's critique of the frontier narrative in America's Vietnam policies and war. Finally (and I see that this is in reverse chronological order), I liked the way that he framed the War of 1898 as a triumph of national (white) unity (which I knew) and Confederate memory-making & the Lost Cause (which I didn't fully grasp in detail until I read this). All in all, there is a lot of valuable material here. There were times when I felt that his underlying argument overwhelmed the story. He sees a stark choice for Americans know between barbarism & socialism, or at least social democracy.