The Hand of the Sun King

I'm still hedging between a 3 and 3.5.

This is not the kind of book that would usually be on my radar but I added this to my TBR as well as requested the arc because I saw how much my favorite reviewer and booktuber Petrik loved it, and wanted to give it a try myself. Now after finishing it, I'm unsure how I feel about it.

I have to start by saying the prose is very very good and you really don't feel like it's a debut while reading it. There's a very engaging quality to the writing and even when I was apprehensive about my enjoyment of the story, I still kept going. The relatively fast pace also helped, but it also had its disadvantages because there were a lot of time jumps in the story, some of which I felt hindered any relationship development. I had read reviews about this one very long ago, so I didn't remember much, but I was pleasantly surprised to realize that this world and part of the cultures were Asian inspired and that always makes me happy. The magic system is elemental but also involves tetragrams and patterns in the world as well as a war between gods and witches, so it was all fascinating to read about but there were some explanations I didn't understand, and I couldn't truly wrap my head around what happened at the end.

This year has seen a lot of books published with empires and colonialism as the norm as rebellion as the core of the story, and this one is no different. But we get to see this story through the eyes of a biracial young man, who has to make a choice between following his mother's heritage and be ostracized for it or take the oath that is laid out to him by his father and become a tool of the empire. This is a coming of age story and we see Alder grow as the book goes on, but this journey was definitely bumpy. He is a petulant child who grows up in privilege, even if deprived of love, and basically wants to do what he wants instead of others dictating his choices. He hardly understands right from wrong, doesn't try much to know the world beyond his bubble, and acts impulsively that lead to drastic consequences. He never thinks first before acting and only learns from his mistakes. I did however understand his hunger for knowledge, but at the same time it also manifested as a hunger for unbridled magic. It wasn't till almost the end that I finally saw that he could be more than his ambition, and can use his magic to fight the oppressive empire.

There are many characters who come and go from his life, but he remains the center of this story. There were only two characters who left a good impression one me - his grandmother who taught him the ways of her people and developed the curiosity in him; his tutor Koro Ha without whose diligence Alder would never have set on his path towards the empire. Both these characters had his well being in their hearts and were deeply responsible for shaping his personality. The only friend he makes Oriole, and his first love Atar, could have been written with more depth, but I felt that ultimately they both came across as plot devices, who taught him things he needed to know and pushed him onto the path of his destiny. The book would have surely been better if these two relationships were written with more depth.

Finally, I think this is an interesting coming of age story which spans almost a decade of the main character's life. While the world building, prose, and magic system found me fascinated, I found the character and relationship development lacking which ultimately left me dissatisfied. However, it might still be the the book for you, as evidenced by the many glowing reviews this debut has received.

There is definitely an increasing influence of Asian cultural mores in modern fantasy and this is definitely welcome - it has provided a significant shake up to the standard tropes and created some fascinating new worlds to explore in literature. There is an unashamed Asian influence on this debut novel from J.T. Greathouse - the mandarin style schools gives it a very distinctive flavour, reminding me of Poppy War.

The world we are introduced to is one where an empire has conquered many outlying kingdoms using its particular control of magic. Citizens of these conquered parts of the empire are effcetively second class citizens with strong ethnic tensions underlying most of the novel. Each conquered culture had its own magic which the empire has stolen for its own and repressed within the local population.

Our story lead is a half caste, whose father is from the conquering nation. They yearn to wield magic and this is tightly controlled requiring them to be selected as a ‘hand' of the emperor to get trained, requiring them to become top of the mandarin style training school. Loyalties become more complex as they learn more about how the empire works and their role within it.

I really enjoyed this - it was well written with an engaging story development. I look forward to more from this author!

Very good story with great surprising twists, unoriginal but well done background/secondary world; but i simply could not connect to the MC and coudn't care less about the characters, and the book kept fringing on (almost) boring me. Good overall, but i will not return for the rest of the series, or anything else from this author.