The Magicians' Guild
Ratings102
Average rating3.8
This was a reread for me, I first picked up this series 10 years ago and adored it. in fact, it was the series that got me into reading properly. And it inspired in me a love of fantasy that still burns today.
The first book in the trilogy is a fair bit different to how I remember it, the plot moves slower than I remembered. Nevertheless I enjoyed the book and it's many characters. I get a good sense of the people in this book and their mannerisms and relationships. While some characters and their plotlines are boring and predictable for me, overall the book was a very interesting and engaging read.
I will say that the book does more for the trilogy as a whole than it does for itself. And by that I mean that the plot of book one is not particularly complex or compelling. Rather, the book sets the world up well and builds a strong network of characters I feel connected to. This means it sets up the following two books very well indeed without being considerable as a standalone. Actually I wouldn't read this if it were a standalone. But the plot of the trilogy will uphold the first book enough that the development makes it worth it.
I encourage everyone to try the series, particularly the second book. It's a strong favourite of mine.
The book seems to be written in the 70s, when people didn't yet know to write good fantasy novels. WAY too slow, too much focus on mundane activities. And for what I have seen, this will be a book about a young kid learning how to be a wizard. I hate “learning how to be a whatever” stories.
Reading the other reviewers, 50% of the book, 300 pages, is about the kid running away because she is afraid she has angered the magician's guild. Not interesting.
Read 1:45 / 14:17 12%
A book that has been sitting on my shelf for too long and it did not disappoint!
I love each of the characters, I love the hiorchary of the magicians and the darkness that surrounds them.
Engaging read. Trudi Cadavan does not disappoint
I enjoyed the book more than i thought i would. Twist awalnya menarik, namun sempat membosankan kare alurnya yg lambat. Ditebus di klimaks 2 bab terakhir. Overall aku suka seri ini.
Still so good on a reread!
I will admit that this time I did notice that some of the dialogue is a little stilted (and the overuse of character's names in dialogue drives me nuts!) however it was the author's debut and I know it gets better in the later books and her other series.
DNF - PG 50
Why?
Mostly because I'm bored out of my mind whenever I actually manage to convince myself to read it. And that's not very often - I don't even think I've opened the book in the past two weeks. Then, I wanted to see how long the plot continued to be the absolutely uninteresting main character avoiding the mostly uninteresting magicians through very uninteresting means. Discovered it was about half the book and decided then that this isn't the book for me.