A Story of Astronomical Rivalry and the Pioneers of Planet Hunting
A Story of Astronomical Rivalry and the Pioneers of Planet HuntingThe Neptune File is the first full account of the dramatic events surrounding the eighth planet’s discovery, and the story of two remarkable men who were able to “see” on paper what astronomers looking through telescopes for more than 200 years had never seen.On June 26, 1841, John couch Adams, a brilliant young mathematician at Cambridge University, chanced upon a report by England’s Astronomer Royal, George Airy, describing unsuccessful attempts to explain the mystifying orbital behavior of the planet Uranus, discovered 65 years earlier. Adams theorized that Uranus’s orbit was being affected by the gravitational pull of another, as-yet-unseen planet. Furthermore, he believed that he did not need to see the planet to know where it was. Four years later, his daring mathematical calculations pinpointed the planet’s location, but Airy failed to act on them—a controversial lapse that would have international repercussions.Soon after Adams’s “proof,” a rival French astronomer, Urbain Le Verrier, also calculated the planet’s position, and the race was on to actually view it. Found just where Adams and Le Verrier had predicted, the planet was named Neptune—and as the first celestial object located through calculation rather than observation, its discovery pioneered a new method for planet hunting.Drawing on long-lost documents in George Airy’s Neptune scrapbook, which resurfaced at an observatory in Chile in 1999. The Neptune File is a tale of heroes and cranks, amateur astronomers, and knighted celebrities. And the tale continues to unfold. Though 150 years would pass before another planet was “calculated,” since the 1995 discovery of a planet circling star 51 Pegasi dozens of planets have been detected in orbit around distant stars. Yet none of them has ever been seen. Their discovery—and the history of science—owes much to the two men who dared to first place celestial calculation before observation.
Reviews with the most likes.
An entertaining look at the discovery of Neptune (and Uranus), rather than a look at Neptune (and Uranus), revolving (no pun intended) around men of science with strong personalities.
John Couch Adams, Urbain Jean Joseph Le Verrier (yes that is just one person), George Airy, James Challis, Johann Galle all played parts, but it was the revolutionary mathematical theories of Adams and Le Verrier, undertaken at the same time in England and France respectively which made finding Neptune with a telescope possible.
Uranus was the key to Neptune - the reason being that astronomers were unable to resolve the path of Uranus with any certainty - predicted positions were aligned for a year or two, then Uranus went off script. It was Adams and Le Verrier who determined that Uranus was being influenced by another planet - one further from the sun. They set about making calculations to determine where the planet was - and in this way Neptune became the first of the planets to be located mathematically before it was witnessed by telescope. This was all 19th century.
For me it was an interesting book, outside of my immediate interests, but I was glad it came to a close when it did. Standage did well to limit the repetition of the story, which was told in part in non-linear timeline.
Interestingly the end of the book (which talks of the ‘modern' search methods for planets outside our solar system (published 2000, this is now out of date)) talks about Pluto, and foreshadows the removal of its ‘planet' status - (a dwarf-planet now apparently).
I enjoyed the many diagrams throughout the book which assisted in the simple explanations which separate this book from more academic or more detailed works. This is definitely a books for the novice, and I am not sure that those with a thorough understanding of the topic would benefit much from this book.
3.5 stars, rounded up.
p48