The Summer Book Club

Perfectly Within Expectations. Susan Mallery has a type of tale, at least over these last few years at minimum. It isn't quite "Hallmarkie" in that it generally features a group of female leads that share the spotlight, but those who enjoy the Hallmarkie type will likely also enjoy this type of book - particularly the women it is clearly catered for. Yes, the male characters can be a bit wooden and one dimensional, but again, Mallery knows her target audience well, is clearly very popular within it, and clearly these benign affronts work within this space for this author - and aren't ever really "offensive" to anyone. They're simply too cardboard to have any real agency or motivations of their own, and mostly exist to affirm whatever the women in their lives are doing in the moment / serve whatever emotional or physical needs the woman they are paired with may have. Again, perfectly in line with what Mallery's audience clearly expects, and a perfectly fine tale within these confines. If this type of casual, non-preachy, female friendship type of tale is what you're after, you've found a great book within that space. If you're looking for something *more*, no matter how you define "more"... you need to look somewhere else. This is one of those books that isn't really going to challenge anyone or anything, it is more of a comfort read. I won't necessarily say "vacation" read and I despise the term "beach read" because not everyone reads any given type of book at the beach and whatever book you may be reading at the beach is by definition a "beach read", and at 400+ pages it would need to be a decently long vacation for anyone to read this book while on vacation. Still, it is that same kind of relaxing type of read that many ascribe to those scenarios, so perhaps for some it will truly be a "beach read". Very much recommended.