Ratings7
Average rating3.3
In East London in the summer of 1895, Robert Coombes (age thirteen) and his brother Nattie (age twelve) were arrested for matricide and sent for trial at the Old Bailey. Robert confessed to having stabbed his mother, but his lawyers argued that he was insane. The judge sentenced him to detention in Broadmoor, the most infamous criminal lunatic asylum in the land. Shockingly, Broadmoor turned out to be the beginning of a new life for Robert. At a time of great tumult and uncertainty, Robert Coombes's case crystallized contemporary anxieties about the education of the working classes, the dangers of pulp fiction, and evolving theories of criminality, childhood, and insanity. With riveting detail and rich atmosphere, Summerscale re-creates this terrible crime and its aftermath, uncovering an extraordinary story of man's capacity to overcome the past. --
Reviews with the most likes.
In 1895 England, 16-year old Robert confessed to having stabbed his mother and living in the house with her body, his younger brother and an adult friend of the family for 17 days. All were arrested, the brother subsequently released, and the older friend was also convicted though he had no knowledge of the murder. Robert is committed to a hospital for the criminally insane which turned out to be his salvation. He was released, deemed sane, at 30 years of age. Eventually he emigrated to New South Wales, Australia. The author's research has resulted in true and readable narrative of the event and Robert's life. It also meticulously portrays the socio-economic level, mores of the time and the major stories of the day. Summerscale creates a likely scenario of the home life Robert had in what can only be called a dysfunctional household. It's a fascinating story and I am awed by Summerscale's research and perseverance to tell it. After fighting in the war and winning medals for his bravery, he settled again in New South Wales to a life of farming and solitude. Until he befriends a neighbor boy who was being victimized by his step-father. It would seem that Robert understood the rage of the step-father but also the feelings of the boy, as his life seemed so similar. Robert offered to have the boy live with him, which he did for several years, and raised him to be a good citizen, caring and considerate. They remained friends until Robert's death. The author had the good fortune of interviewing that boy when he was over 90 years old, forever grateful to Robert for saving his life.
This was really good. I got a bit bogged down with some of the psychological stuff, but the info on prison and penny dreadfuls was really interesting. I also really enjoyed the epilogue.
Actually pretty boring for a true crime book about a child who murders his mother in Victorian England. But I did think the conclusion was somewhat interesting if a little schmaltzy for my tastes.