Ratings8
Average rating3.5
A Buzzfeed Best Book of September In the vein of Educated and The Glass Castle, Daniella Mestyanek Young's Uncultured is more than a memoir about an exceptional upbringing, but about a woman who, no matter the lack of tools given to her, is determined to overcome. Behind the tall, foreboding gates of a commune in Brazil, Daniella Mestyanek Young was raised in the religious cult The Children of God, also known as The Family, as the daughter of high-ranking members. Her great-grandmother donated land for one of The Family’s first communes in Texas. Her mother, at thirteen, was forced to marry the leader and served as his secretary for many years. Beholden to The Family’s strict rules, Daniella suffers physical, emotional, and sexual abuse—masked as godly discipline and divine love—and is forbidden from getting a traditional education. At fifteen years old, fed up with The Family and determined to build a better and freer life for herself, Daniella escapes to Texas. There, she bravely enrolls herself in high school and excels, later graduating as valedictorian of her college class, then electing to join the military to begin a career as an intelligence officer, where she believes she will finally belong. But she soon learns that her new world—surrounded by men on the sands of Afghanistan—looks remarkably similar to the one she desperately tried to leave behind. Told in a beautiful, propulsive voice and with clear-eyed honesty, Uncultured explores the dangers unleashed when harmful group mentality goes unrecognized, and is emblematic of the many ways women have to contort themselves to survive.
Reviews with the most likes.
DNF. Read about 40% of this book before deciding to stop. I'm a big fan of “cult books” and have read tons of them. Perhaps that was what turned me off of this one. All of the stories seem to bleed together in these survivor tales, and they are all written in the same style.
I want more from them. To me, despite it being incredible what these people have survived, I want more than just a retelling of what they went through moment by moment.
I think this was the straw that broke the camels back, and I'll be staying away from survivor stories for a while.
oh hmmm I love a cult memoir of course and I did find her story to be compelling and well-written. I didn't realize it was also a military memoir–which maybe I should have because the opening is a teaser of her in basic training and wondering if she just joined another cult–and I struggled a bit with that element of it. LIKE...it's terrible that the military put her (and other women, and other people) through such terrible training and treatment, and you can see her struggle between being proud of how much abuse she can stand but also like, realizing it's all fucked up. But then there does remain a certain amount of fundamental acceptance of the war in the Middle East that was like... :/
I'd be interested to read another book from her in like 5-10 years to see how her thinking may or may not evolve on that. IDK.