| #1 | The Fellowship of the Ring | 4.38 |
| #2 | The Count of Monte Cristo | 4.35 |
| #3 | | 3.92 |
| #4 | Frisky Frolicking: Tails From Honeysuckle Farm | 4.5 |
| #5 | Mislaid in Parts Half-Known | 4.21 |
| #6 | Never Whistle at Night: An Indigenous Dark Fiction Anthology - Norris Black
- Amber Blaeser-Wardzala
- Phoenix Boudreau
- Cherie Dimaline
- Carson Faust
- Kelli Jo Ford
- David Heska Wanbli Weiden
- Brandon Hobson
- Darcie Little Badger
- Conley Lyons
- Nick Medina
- Tiffany Morris
- Tommy Orange
- Mona Susan Power
- Marcie R. Rendon
- Waubgeshig Rice
- Rebecca Roanhorse
- Andrea L. Rogers
- Morgan Talty
- D.H. Trujillo
- Richard Van Camp
- Royce Young Wolf
- Mathilda Zeller
- Kate Hart
| 4.04 |
| #7 | | 3.84 |
