| #2 |  Cloud Atlas
| 3.92 |
| #3 |  Signal to Noise
| 3.88 |
| #4 |  Before the Reef Before the Reef
| 5 |
| #5 |  1Q84
| 3.72 |
| #6 |  Little Houses
| 5 |
| #7 |  Exiles and Expatriates
| 5 |
| #8 |  Sabrina & Corina
| 4.13 |
| #9 |  When the Whales Leave
| 4 |
| #10 |  Sharks in the Time of Saviors
| 4.21 |
| #11 |  White Plains
| 5 |
| #12 |  Milkman
| 3.7 |
| #13 |  The Secret History
| 4.05 |
| #14 |  McSweeney's 62: The Queer Fiction Issue
| 5 |
| #15 |  McSweeney's Issue 64
| 4 |
| #16 |  The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao
| 3.75 |
| #17 |  Men Without Women
| 3.83 |
| #18 |  McSweeney's Issue 65 | 5 |
| #19 |  McSweeney's Issue 66 | 5 |
| #20 |  Fates and furies
| 3.83 |
| #21 |  The Monsters of Templeton
| 3.5 |
| #22 |  McSweeney's Issue 67
| 5 |
| #23 |  McSweeney's Issue 68
| 5 |
| #24 |  McSweeney's Issue 69 | 2.5 |
| #25 |  McSweeney's Issue 70 | 4 |
| #26 |  McSweeney's Issue 71 (McSweeney's Quarterly Concern): The Monstrous and the Terrible | 5 |
| #27 |  Florida
| 3.77 |
| #28 |  A Tale for the Time Being | 4.09 |
