Ratings1
Average rating3
Series
20 primary booksDr. Gideon Fell is a 20-book series with 20 primary works first released in 1933 with contributions by John Dickson Carr.
Series
2 primary booksPatrick Butler is a 2-book series with 2 primary works first released in 1949 with contributions by John Dickson Carr.
Reviews with the most likes.
For most of its 240 pages, this is an entertaining Gothic mystery. It falls down badly at the end, as a lengthy conversation reveals all the answers to questions raised in the story. It is curiously flat and lacking in narrative drive in the last pages, a surprisingly weak denouement from a writer famous for atmosphere and tension in his books. It is nominally a Gideon Fell mystery, but Fell is rarely in it, and the “solution” is unveiled by the main character, Patrick Butler. Butler is not a success as a character, coming across like a minor character in a forties movie melodrama, all arrogance and bluster. One of the weakest Carr novels I've read. Not recommended.