How It All Began

Humbug. What a poorly-written, pretentious little thought-experiment disguised as a novel. In case you haven't been beaten over the head with it in books, TV and film there's this thing called Chaos Theory–usually explained by the Butterfly Effect; Lively starts off with one event and then examines how the butterfly of an elderly woman's mugging effects the lives of 20 or so others.

As far as that goes...a decent setup. But we have to keep revisiting the conceit, every few chapters we have to have a recap that all of the things going on are because of this mugging. Over and over again. And about halfway through (minor spoiler), we get this big lecture about Chaos Theory. Juuuust in case we haven't got it yet.

When she's not browbeating us with that, Lively tells some okay stories. With the stress on “tells”, rarely, if ever, showing.

The best thing I can say is that at least Lively doesn't interrupt really appealing characters in the middle of fun, compelling stories with this application of Chaos Theory.

An elderly woman gets mugged.

That's how it all began.

Like the butterfly (what is the illusion? the butterfly breathing in the rainforest? the butterfly knocking its pupa onto a jaguar when it emerges?) in the well-known paradigm, this single act sets all kinds of crazy, unrelated events in motion. For better or worse (most seem to be both).

It's an absolutely delightful story. It's one that you won't regret reading. I promise.