With Selections from the Objections and Replies
Ratings17
Average rating3.8
In Descartes's Meditations, the thinker rejects all his former beliefs in the quest for new certainties. He develops new conceptions of body and mind to create a new science of nature. This new translation includes a wide-ranging, accessible introduction, notes and full selections from the Objections and Replies.
Reviews with the most likes.
Descartes goes about trying to decide, if all beliefs are eliminated, what indisputable truths remain? He goes very quickly from “I can't be sure I'm not just a brain in a vat” to “God definitely exists”. It's a fascinating and immensely flawed exercise. He references simple mathematics a bit (of course) and it seemed to me that his exploration was not dissimilar from Euclid's Elements but in the Euclid, he starts with assuming there are five axioms. If you change those axioms, you end up with an entirely different geometry. In this case, Descartes belief in God feels more like an axiom than a derived truth. So his declaration of rational truths could be said to be Descartian God truth, with the existence of a deity as an axiom and ostensibly a different set of truths could easily be derived by assuming the non-existence of God. It was a fun short read but by the end it became a slight slog since the “reality” that was being discussed did not feel convincing.
Featured Prompt
2,097 booksWhen you think back on every book you've ever read, what are some of your favorites? These can be from any time of your life – books that resonated with you as a kid, ones that shaped your personal...
Featured Series
1 released bookCambridge Philosophical Texts in Context is a 5-book series first released in 1641 with contributions by René Descartes, Michael Moriarty, and Çiğdem Dürüşken.