The Beginning of Everything

I love this book. I LOVE this book. I have so much to say about this book.

First NO spoilers section:

This book is a terrific, thoughtful novel. I recommend reading it after the Great Gatsby, which it references often and draws beautiful, creative parallels with. I quite by accident read them at the same time, which ended up being perfect. (More on this in the spoiler section). It is first person from a the perspective of a teenage guy, and it is flawless. Ezra is incredibly easy to relate to and realistic. Honestly, Ezra is one of my favorite leads I've ever read.
The other characters were well done too. Everyone is complicated and flawed. I love Toby so much, and the whole group of friends. I also like how even the more difficult characters were shown sympathetically. In many stories of this nature they would play the bullies or bad guys, but they aren't given such cardboard roles here. They are given reasons for their actions, and understanding. Many even are shown in good moments. I love that about this.
I had very mixed feelings about the female lead, Cassidy, but even that felt like the author if not encouraged at least allowed. She is whimsical and strange almost to the point of being a “manic pixie dream girl” but then each time she pulls back from the edge. She feels quirky but real and possible. She is human. She is damaged. Sometimes she's even annoyingly pretentious. And it's perfect. She isn't glorified or flawless as can be the problem with this type of character. So my mixed feelings on her actually felt like a good thing in this story.

I also just recently read another story about someone with a medical condition (We were liars) and it was interesting to see the different ways of handling it. Ezra in this one doesn't want pity, but he craves understanding and he doesn't chaff over people's kindness–mostly. It was a very interesting depiction. I loved it.

The book is a surprisingly optimistic look at personal tragedy. I 100% recommend to anyone. Very very original and different. And in case you are curious? The novel has a perfect ending.


**Spoilers ahead, read on with caution****
I am going to assume if you are still reading than you have read the book, if not go away!

I love the ending. I was actually actively hoping Cassidy and Ezra would not end up together. As I said before, I had really mixed feelings. Sometimes she would do something charming and sweet and I would like her, but in other scenes she drove me nuts. I hated how she constantly seemed disappointed with him. I get that she was trying to push him to be more original, but when Ezra at the end said he was tired of not being good enough for her it made me so happy. Because it sometimes felt like she wasn't happy with him just being himself. I also loved so much when Ezra realized that he was the one who changed his life, not this girl. She was just along for the ride but he did all the hard work. Then the other amazing part was how as I said above, she sometimes felt like a manic pixie dream girl, but at the end Ezra realizes she did it on purpose. She wanted him to think of her as quirky and weird, but really she was just hiding behind that. She wanted to be remembered as that, but it wasn't her. I loved that twist.

I also liked how things with Luke never really resolved, because sometimes those things don't. Sometimes you don't have the moment where you either change the jerks mind or show them up. Sometimes you just graduate and both move on with your lives. It was well done.

And the Gatsby parallels! They were perfect. There were the obvious ones where Ezra compared his life to Gatsby, but there were others. When he talked about people's personal tragedies at the end by calling them their dust heaps (referencing the dust heaps from the book). There was even a line in the novel that with different words had a complete parallel with the last line in Gatsby (the ceaselessly beat back...). Even the fact that it was East Wood (paralleling with East Egg) and how they all had to escape it. I loved it.

“There's a word for it," she told me, "in French, for when you have a lingering impression of something having passed by. Sillage. I always think of it when a firework explodes and lights up the smoke from the ones before it."

Well, I'm disappointed. This book tried so hard to be meaningful, but the execution just fell flat. I liked the overall message and the ending, in particular, however I was much too detached from the actual plot and characters throughout almost the entire the book.

Ezra, the lead, was all right at times, quite self-absorbed and kinda boring other times, but the rest of the characters were decidedly shallow and stereotypical; they all fit too neatly into boxes: the “mean-girls” clique made up of dump blond cheerleaders, douchey, stupid jocks that torment pseudo hipster nerds with chic hobbies and Ezra's “lady friend” - the embodiment of the ultimate Manic Pixie Dreamgirl. This was not a happy mix and frankly, their interactions just bored me, in a “been there, done that, bought the T-shirt” kind of way.

Like I said, I didn't mind Ezra too much (yet the author could have done so much more with his character), I liked the writing, the beginning was very promising, but then Cassidy (Manic Pixie Dreamgirl multiplied by a million)came into the picture and ruined the book. I felt no chemistry between her and Ezra. Her demeanor was so irritating and tiresome and so were all her quirks and all those hints about her mysterious, tragic past.

Since we're at the tragic past, I saw that “twist” coming miles away, hence another reason why this book had zero impact on me. Even after my suspicions were confirmed, I couldn't bring myself to care for her. And nothing seemed genuine. It felt like a unnecessary plot device that exists just to amp up the drama. I was happy that at least they didn't get back together.

Like a roller coaster: it started on a high but it was all downhill from there.

Okay. So, this book broke my heart. Not because it was bad though, because this book was so fucking amazing. I read it in around two days only because I stayed up until 4am reading even though I had uni early the next morning - for some reason I was just so fucking committed to this book.

The thing about this book is that from when Ezra meets Cassidy you assume the whole book is a love story, which it is for a brief period of time when Ezra is falling in love with her in a few chapters. This novel is so much more than that. It's about individuality and how no matter what your interest are or what you're good at, you are under no obligation to be confined to a specific clique or social status.

Ezra's character was beautifully written with drastic character development which was relatively subtle throughout the book considering that his live HAD to drastically change due to his accident. Ezra was always ‘different' when he was friends with the jocks because he was smart, witty and his main priority wasn't doing keg stands. Although he didn't know his true potential until his accident his character development seems to flow so naturally.

What made me really love this book was the very last chapter, where he is in college and wonders what has happened to Cassidy. I love the reality of this. Cassidy's character was one of the most realistic in the novel (and of course the most unrealistic being Charlotte, but I mean you can't have a book about high school without vapid, materialistic, social climbing cheerleaders); her decision to keep away from Ezra after figuring out his car had collided with Owen's instead of going back to him was the most realistic anyone would have made. She knew that realistically, love wouldn't fix everything. And ALSO realistically, you don't keep in touch with someone that has broken your heart and I love that he had no idea where she was or what she was going. There was some sort of beauty in that I can't really explain.

Ugh. There's so much more I love about this book I can't even begin to articulate everything else. It's amazing, I thoroughly enjoyed it and I think anyone that is a fan of realistic young adult fiction HAS to read this. Right now.

I think I picked this up when it was a Kindle Daily Deal and held onto it until I needed a quick portable read. I've seen it on some John Green-readalike lists, and yeah, it's got the Quirky Smart Kids with Tragic Happenstances down pretty pat. Reading this kind of felt like a rollercoaster (as pictured on the cover!) Or really, a reverse roller coaster. I started off high, because I do love that John Green-y quirky kids thing, and this starts off strong. Then in the middle I got a little weary of it and felt like it was getting pretty predictable. Then, high note ending!! Not what I predicted!

Not necessarily groundbreaking YA fiction, but if you (or your teens) like This Kind of Thing, I'd recommend it.

Diversity note: casually-but-definitely Jewish protagonist.

PS I FORGOT TO MENTION: THE DOG DIES

May i be completely honest? Ezra is just meh. He is oblivious of so much it is a wonder he is not a hated self centered bastard of a character, but seriously, that's most of the redeeming factor here. He is 17, has not much of a personality or self awareness, and I must have been reading too many adult novels because all I could think of was, he could make a great hero ten years from now.

I could say it is because I'm too old for his obvious youth and freshness, but I've just finished two other YA that totally talked to me, so it was just Ezra's lack of dimension, truth and appeal.


I didn't hate it. But I'm very far from recommending it.

Um quase favorito do ano (pensamentos em breve)
obs: a autodestruição da Cassidy que fez a quinta estrela evaporar.