Ratings34
Average rating4.1
The Ninth Rain has fallen. The Jure'lia are awake. Nothing can be the same again.
Tormalin the Oathless and the fell-witch Noon have their work cut out rallying the first war-beasts to be born in Ebora for three centuries. But these are not the great winged warriors of old. Hatched too soon and with no memory of their past incarnations, these onetime defenders of Sarn can barely stop bickering, let alone face an ancient enemy who grow stronger each day.
The key to uniting them, according to the scholar Vintage, may lie in a part of Sarn no one really believes exists - a distant island, mysteriously connected to the fate of two legendary Eborans who disappeared long ago.
But finding it will mean a perilous journey in a time of war, while new monsters lie in wait for those left behind.
Featured Series
3 primary booksThe Winnowing Flame Trilogy is a 3-book series with 3 primary works first released in 2017 with contributions by Jen Williams.
Reviews with the most likes.
4 - 4.5 ⭐️
This was a great second entry - we got way more revelations (some of which straight up crazy), way more character and relationship complexity and all things hit all the fans.
Beware though, this was a rather frustrating read at times, mostly because so many bad things happened in so many unexpected ways.
P.S.: Vincenza “Vintage” De Grazon is a saint and deserves way better!!!
This was a repeated DNF starting in February. But at page 250 I finally pushed forward due to increased action and at page 400 figured out my issue: every character was in conflict with each other and this really put me off. But wow, that action really picked up and the last half was fantastic. “The Ninth Rain” felt a bit more like an adventure and mystery, while this one was a bit more character development (not in a great way) and it turned into a battle. I'm definitely excited for the final book.
Contains spoilers
Compared to the first in the trilogy, this was more solid than compelling. It felt like some events in this were simply there to propel the plot, rather than being natural extensions of the plot. Also, I am not entirely convinced by the way to action scenes are written; they feel underwritten and confused (one scene of conflict felt more like slapstick than action, and I am not sure that was intended).
In any event, this kept me involved enough to want to read the conclusion of the trilogy (if only to discover if the slightly weird reveal that Eborans were created by aliens pays off in some way).