Ratings41
Average rating4
I really expected to love this book. I loved the concept.
I believe a group of marginalized women could get together, and in admitting their sexual beings with desires and fantasies, start a journey toward liberation.
The problem is that it wasn't presented as a journey. The women shared the stories without hesitation and then everything was good.
Two women don't care for each other much, and then they do. One of these women has an issue with the nature of the class ... and then she doesn't.
A couple is not close, and then they have a night of better sex, and their marriage is fixed.
I had trouble finding satisfaction in the book, because there always seemed to be a needed step or scene missing in order for any plot line to resonate or for me to feel like the various resolutions were earned.
We're told how dangerous it is for these women to share their stories, but that never comes to fruition. The danger in the book is over something else entirely, only joined with this main plot by a general misogynistic umbrella.
I noticed multiple editorial errors such as missing words.
The biggest issue is that a contradictory information about a necklace worn by a character. She says the necklace belonged to a female friend who died, and was given to her by the friend's mother, and since that day (that her friend died and her friend's mother gave her the necklace) she has worn it every day.
Just a few pages later she says:
I didn???t have an ounce of sympathy for him. At his funeral, I wore Gulshan???s necklace for the first time. People stared but they said nothing. They all knew.???
This is not the author's fault. Things change in between drafts, and it's hard to keep track. That's why there are editors. Still, moments like that took me out of the book.
I hope to read more by this author.