Half Sick of Shadows

300th REVIEW*

A worthy book for my 300th review here on Goodreads. A fantastical, Arthurian story with a sick cover (see what I did there) and great characters to match. I get some of the reviews critiquing the jumpiness of the story, and I will admit even I (who prides herself on being able to keep track of times and scenes in books) got a bit muffed every so often, but it didn't obscure my delight to have read Sebastin's fantasy. Lovely book, and if you want a book that's as badass as the cover, “Half Sick of Shadows” is a contender.

CW: suicide, bullying, descriptions of drowning

Though I've only read the author's debut Ash Princess before and never managed to continue the trilogy, she is fun to follow on Twitter and I've been very excited for this book since it's announcement. But now I'm pretty unsure of my feelings after finishing it.

I know Arthurian legends are very famous and probably familiar to most western readers from a young age. But I didn't grow up knowing them, and my only knowledge is pretty limited to the show Merlin and the books The Mists of Avalon, which I encountered less than a decade ago, both of which I don't remember much of. So I'm not exactly attached to the original mythos and I don't have the usual complaints like other reviewers, that it diverges too much from the original.

My problem is mostly with the plot itself. I frankly didn't find the non linear timeline structure of the story too difficult, and it was actually interesting to read the “future” chapters and imagine all the various possibilities. It was just that all of the past chapters felt very detached, so when our group of ensemble characters in the present timeline pledge undying loyalty to each other and tell that they would do anything to make Arthur king, I couldn't find it emotionally engaging because I couldn't understand why they were actually so close and loyal to each other.

The characters themselves are interesting, I especially loved Elaine because she is kind of a tragic figure, unable live her life properly as she is always thinking about future possibilities and betrayals and how to change them. I really wanted her to have a life where she got what she wanted. Morgana is another character I loved because she is fierce and impulsive, but always remains true to herself. I think I would enjoyed the book more if more of these two women's dynamic was explored. Gwen is a warrior who gets to make difficult decisions for the sake of her love and her people, but I didn't feel much of anything towards her. Even the romance between Lancelot and Elaine, or Gwen and Arthur were just peripheral subplots that didn't have much impact. Arthur himself wasn't much of a major figure in this book, but I knew that going in because the author herself mentioned it many times, so it didn't bother me much.

To be honest, I don't even know where I'm going with this review. It was an okay story, but I could never understand what the goal or ending we were going towards, and I'm not sure if I'm satisfied with the ending, though it was an interesting surprise. I probably could have loved this more if I could've felt connected to the characters, but alas that didn't happen. I don't know to whom I can recommend this book, but definitely not to those who are very attached to the Arthurian legends and would be unhappy with such a drastically different retelling.

DNF.

After 300+ pages, I just felt like I was slogging, forcing myself to reach the end. I finally admitted that I needed to cut bait.

The story started off with promise that it would tell the story of the King Arthur legend from the perspective of the Lady of Shalott (which I continue to write as “shallot” —don't judge). Solid premise. But the hand wringing about the decisions made or unmade for 100s of pages just made me dread picking it up everyday to continue to read. I know this isn't going to end well and there isn't even a sliver of hope left.

I'm not a rose-colored glasses person usually but I feel like there needs to be some joy in Camelot.